Pumpkin apple pie

Prep time: 15 min
Total time: 1 hr 05 min
Serves: 1 pie

Pumpkin Apple Pie

Pumpkin Filling
1 - egg
½ cup - dark brown sugar, lightly packed
½ cup - pumpkin purée
¼ cup - milk
¼ cup - cream, 36%
1 tbsp - flour
¼ tsp - cinnamon, ground
1/8 tsp - ginger, ground
1/8 tsp - nutmeg, ground
1/8 tsp - clove, ground
Pinch - salt

Apple Filling
2 cups - Granny Smith apple (approx. 1½ apples)
1 tbsp - tapioca
½ tsp - cinnamon, ground
¼ tsp - dark brown sugar

1 9-inch pie shell

Sautéed Apples
1 tsp - butter
1 tbsp - dark brown sugar
Pinch - cinnamon, ground

Preheat oven to 365F.

In a medium bowl lightly whisk the egg and brown sugar. Add the pumpkin purée, milk and cream and mix until well blended. Add the remaining pumpkin filling ingredients and stir to combine. Do not over mix.

To make the apple filling, peel the apples and cut into half-inch thick slices, removing the core. Set aside 12 slices for garnish. In a medium bowl, stir together tapioca, cinnamon and sugar, then toss the remaining apple slices in the mixture.

Fill the bottom of the pie shell with the apple filling, then pour the pumpkin filling overtop of the apples. Place the pie on a large baking sheet to catch any spills. Bake for 50 minutes or until the filling is set and crust has browned.

While the pie is baking, heat butter in a frying pan over medium high heat. Combine the sugar and cinnamon and coat the 12 reserved apples. Sauté them in the pan until soft. Remove from heat and set aside.

Once the pie is baked, let cool on a wire rack. Garnish with the sautéed apples and serve with whipped cream or vanilla ice cream.

Print Recipe

Shop This Recipe

  • GoldEgg Omega 3 Eggs Large white (dozen)

    Price $4.59
  • Rogers Sugar Best Brown (1kg)

    Price $3.59
  • ED Smith 100% Pure Pumpkin (796ml)

    Price $3.69
  • Dairyland 2% Milk (1L)

    Price $2.29
  • Dairyland Whipping Cream 36% Old Fashioned (1L)

    Price $5.69
  • Robin Hood All Purpose Flour (2.5kg)

    Price $5.99
  • Morton Bassett Cinnamon Ground (75g)

    Price $10.99
  • Morton Bassett Ginger Ground (71g)

    Price $10.99
  • Morton Bassett Whole Cloves (38g)

    Price $17.99
  • Sifto Table Salt Slim Pack (1kg)

    Price $1.59
  • Apples, Granny Smith (each)

    Price $1.45
  • Minit Tapioca (225g)

    Price $2.99
  • Tenderflake Pie Shells 9" 2pk (320g)

    Price $3.99
  • Dairyland Creamery Butter (454g)

    Price $5.49
Signature Sunterra
Friday Night Feast


Let us make Friday nights easy
Cooking Classes
Fresh Rewards
Feature Stories
About Us


We are farmers, butchers, chefs, bakers and baristas. But above all else, we are passionate food experts.

Learn more
Work with Sunterra


We value our Team Members as much as our loyal customers, and we want you to be part of our amazing team.

Come see what it’s like to work with us
Online Newsletter


Sign up for our biweekly newsletter to keep up-to-date on new products, find new recipes and learn what items Fresh Rewards members can get for free.

Sign up
Our Community


The Sunterra ROOTS program defines our behaviour and commitment to the community. We believe in reciprocity, opportunity, openness, trust and service.

Learn more
MARKETbar by Sunterra

MARKETbar by Sunterra

Located on the third floor of Sunterra Market Keynote, MARKETbar offers fresh, casual food in a beautiful modern setting with great views of the city.

Take a look inside